Republicans’ Tax Lies Show the Rot Spreads Wide and Runs Deep – Paul Krugman – NYT

“On Thursday morning, The New York Times revealed that Steven Mnuchin, the Treasury secretary, has been lying for months about Republican tax plans. Mnuchin has repeatedly claimed the existence of a Treasury report that — unlike every independent, nonpartisan assessment — found that these plans would pay for themselves, increasing growth and hence revenues so much that the deficit wouldn’t rise. But there is no such report, and never has been; Treasury staffers weren’t even asked to study the issue.

Also on Thursday, John McCain — who has delivered sanctimonious lectures on the importance of “regular order” in the Senate — declared his support for the G.O.P. tax bill. Remember, Senate leaders rushed this bill to the floor without holding any hearings or soliciting expert testimony (and tax policy is an area where you really, really need to hear from experts, lawyers and accountants even more than economists). In fact, at the time McCain declared his support, some key provisions were still secret, so they could be presented for a vote with no time for debate.

McCain declared that he had made his decision after “careful consideration.” Careful consideration of what? He didn’t even wait for an analysis of the bill’s economic impact by the Joint Committee on Taxation, Congress’s own scorekeeper — the only official assessment, since the Trump administration was, as I said, lying when it claimed to have its own analysis.Later that day the joint committee delivered its predictable verdict: Like all other reasonable studies, its review found that the Senate bill would do little for U.S. economic growth, while directly hurting tens of millions of middle-class Americans, blowing up the deficit, lavishing benefits on the wealthy and opening up new frontiers for tax avoidance. But thanks to the moral collapse of McCain and other supposedly principled Republicans, at the time this column was filed the bill nonetheless seemed on track to clear the Senate.”

David Lindsay:  Thank you Paul Krugman. It is easy to give in to despair, upon such grave and dismal anlaysis. I consoled one despondent friend recently, that the pendulum will swing back in the direction of progessive democracy, unless there is a right wing coup. Economists on both sides of the aisle have been suggesting for years that a 20% corporate tax rate makes a great deal of good sense, when coupled with eliminating the myriad loop holes, that allow many corporation to pay less than 20%, even zero percent, when many smaller companies pay much more than 20%. This 20% corporate tax rate might well be something to build on, Paul Krugman is right, as usual, when he ends his piece saying the only solution to GOP bullying and lies now is through electoral politics. The way to get back to environmental sanity, probity and compassion, is by dilligence at the ballot box. Lets give the pendulum a little push.
David Lindsay Jr is the author of The Tay Son Rebellion, Historical Fiction of Eighteenth-century Vietnam, and blogs at

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s